Romans 14.10-13,
Isaiah 45.18-25.
One of the many things about the ancients—and therefore the bible, ‘cause it’s ancient—which confuses Christians, especially kids, is the idea of collective guilt, collective responsibility, and collective punishment. Because it’s not how our culture works anymore. You don’t punish a whole family, a whole city, a whole state, a whole religion, a whole country, a whole ethnicity, for the acts of one person, or a few people. Isn’t that in fact a crime against humanity? A war crime? Doesn’t it violate the Geneva Convention?
You may not be aware the reason moderns think this way, is because Paul set the precedent right here in Romans 14: The idea God doesn’t judge entire people-groups, but individuals. The idea we individually stand before God, and have to individually answer for our sins and trespasses, and get individually rewarded or penalized for them. This idea is hinted at many times in the scriptures, but it’s spelled out pretty explicitly in today’s passage.
Thing is, the other idea—that you and I are part of a society, part of a collective, part of a tribe or nation or commonwealth, and if one of us sins we can bring down the whole—is all over the bible too. So much so, Christians will even claim
True, there are Old Testament passages where God punishes all Israel because the vast majority of the population is sinning themselves sticky. Yeah, sometimes he orders Israel or its judges to wipe out an entire Amorite city, including any children who might grow up and feel duty-bound to avenge their wicked forebears, because the city’s sins are just so vile. Collective guilt and punishment is found all over the bible. But those who are quick to condemn this behavior when they think God’s committing it, forget God frequently made exceptions to these genocidal-sounding orders. Like sparing Noah and his family
Paul saw God’s tendency to judge individuals, not the collective, in the scriptures. Which is why he could confidently say the following when he corrected Roman Christians about criticizing one another, especially
Romans 14.10-13 KWL 10 You:¹ Why do you judge your¹ fellow Christian?- Or you¹ too: Why do you look down on your¹ fellow Christian?
- For all of us will present ourselves before God’s judgment seat,
11 for this was written:- “The Master says this: ‘I live.
- Everyone will bend the knee to me.
- Every tongue will confess God.’ ”
Is 45.23 12 Therefore each of us, by ourselves,- will give a word to God,
13 so we should no longer judge one another.- Instead, judge this all the more:
- Don’t place an obstacle before a fellow Christian,
- nor something to trip them up.
’Cause you do realize some of the reason Christians are so adamant about condemning and penalizing every single misdeed, is this irrational, unjustified fear God’s gonna condemn the whole. I’ve heard so many Christian nationalists insist unless we ban this or that sin from the United States, God’s gonna smite our nation with the worst plagues and famines and natural disasters we’ve ever seen. (And that’s saying something, considering the Great Recession, the
Therefore neither the nationalists nor us have any basis for persecuting Christians who sin differently than we do. They individually answer to God. As do you. As do I. He knows whether we’ve been following Jesus, whether we’ve been listening to the Holy Spirit, whether we’ve behaved consistently with Jesus’s teachings and our consciences, and how much of it was earnest and how much was